Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links in this post are affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, I may earn a small commission if you click through and make a purchase. This helps support the content on this site. I only recommend products I genuinely believe in. Thank you for your support!
If you’re like me, you’ve probably amassed a collection of tools over the years—some were impulse buys, some came highly recommended, and others seemed like the best option at the time. But here’s the problem: all those tools probably use different batteries. Right now, my setup includes a 12V Milwaukee, 18+ and 40V Ryobi, 12V Bauer, a Dremel, a 20V Dewalt, and a Festool. And I’m probably forgetting a couple!
Keeping track of batteries for each one feels like a logistical nightmare. You have to keep them charged, which means juggling battery chargers, hoping they’re topped off when you need them, and then replacing them over time. And while it’s good practice to have a few batteries ready, having too many brands adds a whole new level of chaos. Here’s why sticking to just two tool brands—and ideally only one yard equipment brand—might be one of the best decisions you make for your workshop.
The Battery Problem: Why It Matters More Than You Think
Most power tool brands use proprietary battery systems. What this means is, once you buy a drill, driver, or any other tool in that line, you’re basically committing to that battery ecosystem. Dewalt’s 20V batteries are only going to work on Dewalt tools, just as Milwaukee’s M18 batteries are exclusive to Milwaukee tools. If you’re using multiple brands, you’re stuck with a dozen different batteries, and each one has to be managed separately. This is more than just an inconvenience; it also becomes a financial burden over time, especially as batteries wear out and need replacing.
The Dilemma of Lithium-Ion Batteries: The 100% Charge Issue
Most tools these days run on lithium-ion batteries, which are powerful and lightweight but require careful handling to maximize their lifespan. The catch? While it might seem smart to keep these batteries fully charged and ready for action, storing them at 100% isn’t great for their long-term health. Studies on lithium-ion battery chemistry reveal that storing batteries at a full charge can actually lead to capacity loss over time, meaning your batteries will gradually hold less charge as they age.
According to a study on battery health, lithium-ion batteries degrade faster when stored at a full charge because of the high voltage stress on the battery’s internal chemistry. The reality, though, is that most of us need to keep batteries charged and ready for whatever project comes up next, so it’s a bit of an unavoidable trade-off. Unfortunately, for those of us managing multiple tool brands and their various battery sizes, this just adds to the frustration of battery upkeep.
How to Simplify: Choosing the Right Brands for the Job
So, what’s the best approach? If you’re a light DIYer, it might be best to stick to a single brand—ideally, one with a comprehensive lineup of tools at a reasonable price. Ryobi, for example, is a fantastic choice here. They’ve got a wide range of tools, many of which are perfect for casual home projects. Their tools aren’t necessarily meant for heavy-duty, everyday use, but for the weekend warrior, they’re more than sufficient.
For more serious DIYers or pros, a two-brand approach is the way to go. Here’s how you can make it work:
- One Primary Brand for Heavy Rotation Tools: Invest in a durable, high-performance brand like Dewalt or Milwaukee for the tools you use most frequently. Their batteries tend to last longer, and the tools themselves are built for tough, repeated use. Dewalt’s 20V line and Milwaukee’s M18 line are both excellent choices for high-rotation, power-intensive tools.
- Dewalt 20V Tools: See them here
- Milwaukee M18 Tools: See them here
- Secondary Brand for Light Use Tools: For tools that see less action, go with a more budget-friendly option. Ryobi is a good candidate because of its extensive lineup and affordable price point. Their 18+ tools are solid enough for lighter-duty jobs and won’t break the bank if you only pull them out occasionally.
- Single Brand for Yard Equipment: Yard tools are an entirely different beast because they often run on high-voltage batteries—typically 40V or higher. In this category, brands like EGO or Ryobi’s 40V line are excellent because they offer specialized outdoor tools that cover most of your landscaping needs. Sticking to a single brand here will spare you from managing multiple battery types and voltage levels.
The Long-Term Benefits of Brand Consolidation
By limiting yourself to just a couple of brands, you’ll save time, money, and a lot of frustration in the long run. Not only will you streamline your charging setup, but you’ll also minimize the need for frequent battery replacements since you can focus on maintaining fewer batteries overall. This also means fewer replacement batteries to buy over time, and let’s be real—those savings add up.
Plus, you’ll have fewer chargers cluttering up your workspace, which is a nice bonus. And when you’re not juggling half a dozen different battery systems, you’ll find it’s a lot easier to keep your tools ready to go for that next big project.
Final Takeaway: Make It Simple on Yourself
If you’re starting out or rethinking your tool setup, save yourself the hassle and stick to two brands of tools max and one brand for your yard gear. You’ll save time, money, and battery headaches in the long run, and you might even find that your DIY projects are more enjoyable when you’re not constantly scrambling for the right battery or charger. Embrace simplicity, and let your tools work for you—not the other way around.
